Key Points
- Evolution has reached a secret settlement with Calcagni & Kanefsky, LLP, making Black Cube the sole defendant.
- The details of this agreement remain confidential, and Black Cube’s statement about the absence of money transactions in it has not been confirmed yet.
- Playtech is not one of the defendants, and the court must approve any attempt to add it to the suit.
Details of the Settlement Are Confidential
Evolution has agreed with the law firm which presented Black Cube’s report to US regulators. However, the terms of this deal are confidential. Lawyers at Black Cube have called it the “white flag of surrender”, but they haven’t seen the terms of this settlement.
The report was sent to regulators in New Jersey and Pennsylvania in November 2021. Evolution filed a lawsuit in December, and regulators closed the investigations in February 2024 without any action.
Lawyers of Calcagni & Kanefsky confirmed the existence of the settlement during the hearing in New Jersey Superior Court on Tuesday, 17 November. This agreement releases the law firm from the defamation suit, and Black Cube becomes the sole defendant now. They refused to give the details without the court order because of confidentiality clauses.
Unexplained Changes in Playtech’s Share Price
According to NEXT.io, the share price of Playtech fell by up to 10% before recovery right before the hearing. The drop refers to a certain period of the trade, but not the whole day, so it may vary in the range of daily prices. There is no evidence for the cause of this event, so we can’t connect it to the settlement.
Playtech shares often react to the events concerning this lawsuit. For instance, the shares of Playtech lost approximately 21% of value on 21 October 2025 when the company became known as one of the defendants. Jefferies lowered the price target to 240p from 405p.
Implications of the Settlement for the Legal Battle
Playtech is not involved in the legal battle as a defendant despite previous reports that implied Evolution had included the firm. On 5 June 2026, the court dismissed Evolution’s bid to include Playtech, without prejudice, and allowed it to reapply. In order to deal with the anti-SLAPP issue first, the November hearing was crucial to the case. The half-year report of Playtech states the issue as a contingent liability citing the “absence of any claim served on the Group”.
According to UPEPA, defendants may ask to dismiss the lawsuits regarding protected speech before their hearing. If this request is made, it does not imply the truthfulness of the allegations stated in the Black Cube’s report. According to Black Cube, its investigations are based on the truth and protected by UPEPA, citing its previous disclosures. Evolution disagrees with this and states that the commercial activities of Black Cube should be taken into account.
Porto also noted that there is uncertainty about the constitutionality of the use of UPEPA as it is rarely used. Only a search of US case law has shown a limited number of decisions made in relation to UPEPA.
Performance-based Payments in Black Cube’s Contract
It was stated in court documents, reported in November 2025, that Black Cube’s contract contained performance-based payments. These included the initial fee of £400,000, and further £150,000 in case of discovering any proof of misconduct and £175,000 for conducting a large media exposure. There was also a reward of £350,000 in case the regulator conducted the investigation, and it really happened. Finally, the £500,000 payment was related to the loss of Evolution’s gaming license. However, the information on the fulfilment of the last condition is absent in the reports.
The company received £675,000 as rewards for reaching the first three milestones in addition to the initial £400,000 payment. Moreover, according to another agreement that was signed in 2022, new incentives were established.
On 21 October 2025, Playtech stated that it commissioned the investigation due to concerns about the existence of the prohibited gambling markets. Evolution claims that the contract involved planning to induce the regulatory investigations and eventually lose the gaming license.
Findings of Spectrum Gaming Support Various Positions in the Dispute
Evolution hired the Spectrum Gaming Group to investigate the allegations from the Black Cube report. Evidence gathered during the investigation was found to support different positions in the dispute. The results of Spectrum’s testing of VPN services showed that the Evolution games are available in the UAE, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Saudi Arabia. The investigators have not been able to access the games in Iran, Sudan or Syria and considered these allegations “unsupportable and lacking credibility and proper foundation.”
The report also revealed certain problems with the compliance procedures of Evolution but did not find any proof that the company intentionally allowed its games to run in the forbidden territories.
UK Investigation Adds Another Element to Black Cube’s Case
On July 23, 2026, the UK Gambling Commission published the result of its investigation into Evolution Malta Holding. The UK regulator concluded that some Evolution games ran on six unlicensed gambling sites controlled by two companies. During the investigation, the regulator identified certain weaknesses in risk assessments, internal procedures, and customer due diligence. This investigation dealt with the Great Britain market, a different time period, and a different regulator. Therefore, these findings can’t be used to decide the New Jersey lawsuit.
Expert Evaluation: Genuine Problems May Still Be Used for Commercial Purposes
In our opinion, the facts allow making two contradictory arguments at the same time. Spectrum’s report shows that Evolution’s games are in some of the prohibited markets, identified by the Black Cube’s report, whereas the UK Gambling Commission separately identifies genuine problems with the company’s regulatory compliance practices. Even the report identifying actual problems may be used for commercial purposes.
The terms of such contracts where payments depend on regulators’ investigations or press reports deserve special attention. Playtech claims that its worries were genuine, and no court has ruled on the merits of the report yet.
Also, Evolution’s interpretation of the court’s decisions needs closer analysis. Evolution says that its games were ruled to be “not truthful” in the February 2025 decision. However, according to iGaming Business, the decision does not make a final ruling on the merits. The September 2025 order used the phrase “objectively baseless” but only when assessing the allegations from the regulator’s perspective.