Novomatic Is the Majority Owner of Ainsworth and Its Chair Has Resigned, Why?

Novomatic Is the Majority Owner of Ainsworth and Its Chair Has Resigned, Why?

Key Points

  • Novomatic’s representative on the board stepped down due to a lack of confidence in the CEO and independent directors of the company. There is no other reason in the filing.
  • A 95-page shareholder report contains allegations concerning payments and board control. Ainsworth states these claims have yet to be proven and has started an investigation.
  • Two special resolutions proposed at the May AGM failed despite being supported by around 74%, which is under the requirement of 75%.

Novomatic is the majority owner of Ainsworth Game Technology, with a 67.4% share. However, Novomatic’s representative on the board has recently resigned due to a lack of confidence in Ainsworth’s CEO and independent directors. Birgit Wimmer said so herself on 16 November in a company filing. It happened two days after the publication of a 95-page shareholder report on an investor forum.

Why Did the Chair of Novomatic Quit Ainsworth?

Birgit Wimmer was nominated as a member of the Ainsworth board by Novomatic in March this year and resigned from the post with immediate effect on 16 November. According to the company’s filing, she left because of “a lack of confidence in the Independent Non-Executive Board members and the CEO.”

The company thanked her for her work and said that it continues to search for more independent directors, as this process had started in early October. However, the filing shows these concerns only as the personal motives of the member and not as an official position of Novomatic. In addition, her resignation should be seen separately from the fact that Novomatic holds a stake in the company.

The stake in the company gives the owner the right to nominate directors but does not oblige them to stay on the board. Birgit Wimmer’s resignation created a vacancy on the board; however, Novomatic will continue to hold 67.4% of its shares and the voting rights associated with them.

When appointing Birgit Wimmer as a member of the board, Ainsworth did not classify her as an independent director due to her ties to Novomatic and the ownership of shares in the company.

Shareholder’s Report Highlights Eight Issues

On Saturday, 14 November, Kjerulf Ainsworth, the son of founder Len Ainsworth, published a 95-page report on the HotCopper investment forum. The report was compiled by a Queensland-based consultancy firm for the law firm HWL Ebsworth. According to the document, it was based on information provided by 19 current and former employees and was compiled between August 2025 and April 2026.

In the notice dated 30 September, it was reported that Kjerulf’s voting power had grown to 10.56%, compared to 9.55% in early June. Kjerulf claims that he provided the report to Ainsworth’s chief executive officer, chairman and relevant regulators on 10 October prior to publishing it.

There are eight points of concern raised in the report, such as alleged hidden payments to company officers and an A$13.2 million loss in Argentina. Some of the concerns were previously known to the public, but those relating to Ainsworth’s Latin American operations gained little attention.

Among the alleged benefits to Wimmer from Novomatic’s owner, Johann Graf, there is a sum of €1.5 million and a 5% stake in Novo Invest. There is no suggestion in the report that these benefits were improper. Rather, their disclosure is questioned, referring to an Ainsworth director as “a substantial personal beneficiary of the person who controls AGT’s controlling shareholder.”

Ainsworth refutes the claims in the report as well-known facts. The company reports that the document and associated posts online contain “a number of unproven allegations and assertions.” Besides, Ainsworth mentions the background of the author in the fields of public relations, crisis communication, journalism and aviation safety. Ainsworth has requested HWL Ebsworth to comment on the independence of the author and previous connections with Kjerulf.

Ainsworth’s Regulatory and Compliance Committee is leading the investigation process with the help of external experts. Novomatic has consistently rejected all allegations.

Federal Court Gives Permission for Inspection of the Company Documents

On 14 November, the Federal Court of Australia granted permission to Kjerulf to inspect certain documents of Ainsworth with an order made by consent. There is information that the documents contain valuations of the property, transactions of Novomatic starting from February 2017 and minutes of board discussions concerning executive remuneration.

The order also relates to discussions regarding the investigation of Harald Neumann and his appointment of him as director and CEO.

From Novomatic’s A$1 Bid to the Resignation of Wimmer

On 28 April 2025, Novomatic bid for the remaining 47.1% stake in Ainsworth at A1 per share. The offer constituted a 35% premium, but according to Kjerulf, the shares were valued at A3 each.

In July 2025, Kjerulf cited a Valbridge valuation of Ainsworth’s Nevada and Florida operations at A116 million, as against the A68.7 million valuation by the company. Ainsworth’s Target’s Statement in September 2025 stated that Novomatic planned to delist once its ownership reached 75%. It would require 90% to force the remaining shareholders to divest. In this case, Novomatic had 59.8%, falling short of both percentages.

Novomatic scrapped its proposed scheme of arrangement in August 2025 when minority shareholders announced their opposition to the plan. However, Novomatic maintained its A$1-per-share bid offer. Harald Neumann, the former Novomatic CEO and CEO of Ainsworth since October 2021, resigned on 13 October 2025 after being encouraged by Nevada regulators to withdraw his application for a licence.

Ryan Comstock became interim CEO of Ainsworth before receiving his permanent appointment as CEO. It is Comstock whose leadership style is currently under scrutiny by Wimmer. Novomatic abandoned its takeover bid in February 2026 and was left with 67.39% of Ainsworth, lower than the 75% threshold set for delisting. Both Neumann and Graf were charged by Austrian prosecutors in February 2026, and they refute the allegations. The trial will resume soon.

The amendment to the constitution received 74.14% at Ainsworth’s annual general meeting in May and failed. Another proposal about proportional takeover provisions failed even though it received 74.17%. Since both proposals are special resolutions requiring at least 75% of the voting shareholders to approve them, they were unsuccessful. Wimmer won the election at the same meeting with 74.14% approval and 25.85% disapproval.

Kjerulf bought more than two million Ainsworth shares at A1.60 each on 2 June 2026, much higher than Novomatic’s A1 offer. On the same day, Wisconsin’s Forest County Potawatomi Gaming Commission requested information from Ainsworth’s US business. Ainsworth subsequently noted that the regulatory authority had “found that Ainsworth fully complied with all requests.”

On 5 June, chairman Danny Gladstone and the company secretary resigned amid reports of payments of A10 million and A5 million without disclosure.

Expert Analysis: Novomatic Holds Control Over the Company, but the Board Issues Are Questionable

The majority holding by Novomatic does not mean that the company holds control over every shareholder decision. For example, the failure of two Ainsworth May AGM proposals was proven by their 74% support. Our estimate shows that, even taking into account all voting shares, Novomatic’s 67.4% shareholding will be less than the required 75%. Thus, minority shareholders may influence decisions requiring a special resolution.

The resignation of the director can indicate disagreement with some board members on a board that is biased in favour of the majority shareholder. But the filed document indicates only Wimmer’s lack of confidence and does not contain reasons why she made such a decision. However, the proximity in time to Kjerulf’s report cannot prove a relation between those events.

It should be emphasised that her criticism of Ainsworth’s independent directors is reasonable, since their role consists of making decisions that are not biased by the controlling shareholder. Ainsworth started recruiting independent directors in early October, almost at the same time as Kjerulf indicates that he sent his report to Ainsworth’s management. There is no document confirming any connection between those two facts.

Ainsworth emphasises the professional background of the author of the report. Though it is important, it alone does not mean that the allegations made in the report are true. It is necessary to criticise Kjerulf’s position. He is a shareholder who has a competing interest and whose report uses unconfirmed sources’ comments.

To provide investors with information about the results of the investigation conducted by the company, the results should be released. Ainsworth undertakes to inform its stakeholders of the results if it is necessary in accordance with the continuous disclosure policy, but does not promise to release the investigation results.

Some regulators have already investigated some issues associated with Ainsworth. In October 2025, the gaming authority of Nevada considered the position of Neumann. In June 2026, the Wisconsin gaming commission asked Ainsworth for information. There is no information about further actions by those regulators after the resignation of Wimmer, which means that any prediction of their involvement is just guesswork.

Three different procedures have now been started: Austrian legal proceedings, Kjerulf’s analysis of the company’s records and Ainsworth’s investigation. Ainsworth has not specified a deadline for completing the last procedure.