DoubleU Games’ $16.25 Offer and the Failed $17 Bid for DoubleDown

DoubleU Games’ $16.25 Offer and the Failed $17 Bid for DoubleDown

Key Points

  • DoubleU Games claims $16.25 is the highest value its valuation expert can justify as DoubleDown’s purchase price based on a Korea pricing rule.
  • Party A, a competitor’s name, has shown interest in offering $17.00 but there were concerns about its ability to complete the transaction.
  • To acquire the minimum 95% interest, approximately 85% of minority stockholders need to tender their ADSs by 10 December.

DoubleU Games Imposes Limit of $16.25 on DoubleDown’s Purchase as a Rival Indicates Its Interest to Offer $17.00

In acquiring DoubleDown, two figures stood out as the maximum and the highest; $16.25, which DoubleU Games considered its maximum offer and $17.00 which a competitor was interested in offering. This article explains how DoubleU arrived at the limit and the reason why the high offer never materialised according to the SEC filings. On 9 November, DoubleU Games agreed to buy all publicly held ADSs of DoubleDown Interactive at $16.25 each in cash. The offer price is a 44% increase over the initial $11.25 offer in April and a 77% increase over the unaffected closing price of 27 April. In comparison to the closing price on 6 November, the premium is relatively small at about 19.7%.

Initial Offer of $11.25 in April Faces Shareholders’ Rejection after One Week

DoubleU Games first offered $11.25 per ADS on 27 April. At that time, the offer placed the value of DoubleDown shares that DoubleU did not own at approximately $184 million. Additionally, DoubleU Games stated that it will vote in favour of the deal and will not support any other proposal.

After seven days, Four Tree Island Advisory publicly called on DoubleU’s special committee to reject the offer. The top 10 stockholders cited that the offer is far too low and highlighted the implied EBITDA multiple of 0.25 compared to Playtika’s 4.6. Four Tree Island Advisory also reminded that DoubleU paid $18 per ADS in October 2021.

DoubleU Claims Korean Pricing Rule Constraints Its Offer at $16.25

Further negotiations took place starting in September with the proposed price being increased incrementally. On 10 September, Kroll Securities asked DoubleU Games for more details after receiving an unsolicited higher offer from a third party as stated in the Schedule 14D-9 filing of DoubleDown. On 13 September, DoubleU offered a revised bid of $14.50 per ADS stating clearly that it was not final. On 15 September, the special committee made another counter-offer to pay $20.00 per ADS through Kroll Securities. DoubleU stated on 16 September that it couldn’t propose any offer above $16.25. The decision was based on the Korean pricing rule which allowed DoubleU to make a bid no further than 30% from the reference price. On September 17, DoubleU set its reference price to be around $12.50 per ADS, thus providing the allowable price range between $8.75 and $16.25.

Party A Chased DoubleDown for Several Months but Couldn’t Convince Special Committee

The unnamed potential buyer referred to in the case as Party A approached DoubleDown’s chief financial officer, Joseph Sigrist, via an adviser on 27 May. On 25 June, Party A made an offer to buy DoubleDown in a purely cash deal at $15.00 per ADS, putting DoubleDown’s equity value at approximately $744 million. Calculating DoubleU’s price of $16.25 will provide a value of approximately $805 million, $60 million higher. The problem with funding was still under discussion. According to the adviser of Party A, the acquisition would cost about $245 million excluding the cash owned by DoubleDown, but Party A had only $41 million of its own. There was a “highly confident” financing letter dated 2 July covering $250 million worth of new debt. From 7 July, the special committee doubted the effect of the Korean restrictions on financing the acquisition with the target company’s assets.

Kroll’s Valuations Place $16.25 above One Range but Below Another

According to the management’s forecast, the revenues of the company will fall from $354.7 million in 2026 to $229.2 million in 2030, which means a 35.4% fall. Operating income is expected to fall even more, namely 90.4%, to $12.0 million from $124.4 million. Much of this decline would be caused by players exiting third-party platforms, with the assumption that only approximately half will stay. The filing noted that the figures in question “are subject to significant uncertainty.” Using these forecasts, the DCF analysis conducted by Kroll resulted in the valuation range of $14.18 to 14.38 per ADS before withholding tax. The special committee noted that the offer made by DoubleU (16.25) was higher than that valuation range but was lower than the midpoint of Kroll’s earlier valuation range of $15.00 to $20.00. A preliminary valuation made in August also served as a benchmark. According to the filing, Kroll believed that the valuation based on consensus estimates of $25.00 for each share was too optimistic.

Third-Quarter Figures Were Released Two Days Later

Just two days after the takeover agreement, the DoubleDown company reported its third-quarter revenues of $94.3 million, which showed a 1.6% decline. SuprNation, the iGaming division of the company, achieved 7.4% growth to $17.4 million via the Las Vegas platform. Direct-to-consumer sales comprised 58.0% of social casino revenues, compared to 20.9% in the same period in the previous year. Thus, the reduction in platform fees was achieved. Adjusted EBITDA rose 7.2% to $40.2 million, while the profit dropped by 43.9% to $18.4 million due to foreign exchange losses and taxes. The net cash reached approximately $545 million, accounting for roughly two-thirds of the equity value based on the $16.25 offer. For the nine months of 2026, DoubleDown earned $282.7 million in revenue. This means that $72.0 million remains to reach the annual target of management, in comparison with $94.3 million achieved in one quarter only. Management submitted the projections on 24 August, five weeks before the third quarter end.

The Tender Offer Requires More than 50% Approval

The transaction has two separate ownership criteria. First, more than 50% of unaffiliated ADSs must be tendered, which is an irrevocable criterion. The calculation is made excluding DoubleU, its affiliates and the directors and officers of both parties. The second one implies that DoubleU will own at least 95% of all common shares after the offer is made. The conditions for making the offer are outlined in the tender offer documents. Currently, DoubleU owns 67.05% of the company. On this basis, it is necessary to receive 85% of minority shareholders to tender their ADSs in order to reach a 95% ownership level. Reduction of the second ownership threshold to 90%, which equals 69.7% of ADSs included in the offer, is possible provided that certain conditions are fulfilled. These conditions include confirmation by DoubleU that it is impossible to reach the 95% level of ownership, consultation of the special committee and obtaining written consent from DoubleDown. DoubleU is not obliged to make such a reduction. If the offer is closed, non-tendering shareholders will be bought out at the same price according to Korean law. If it does not happen, the procedure becomes different depending on the level of ownership of the company less than 95%. In case the second step fails, the shareholders can end up with shares of a delisted company without liquidity. No appraisal rights are available to ADS holders during the tender offer process. In order to exercise share-purchase rights at a later date, ADS holders should cancel their ADSs. The tender offer expires at 5:00 p.m., New York time, on 10 December, unless extended. It is expected that the transaction will cost DoubleU about $265.4 million, plus fees, via cash and KRW 300 billion bridge financing. The long-stop date is 10 March 2027.

Expert Analysis: Is $16.25 a Fair Price or Just a Legal Cap?

Pricing at no more than 30% remains the open issue in all the papers provided. The company insists that its valuator does not support any offer exceeding the price of $16.25, despite the demand from the advisers of the special committee to get a purchase price of $17.00 and $20.00.

In case the limitation is as firm as DoubleU states, the $20.00 counter-offer was not the realistic option. Party A would be the sole source of pressure for the committee, but its proposal was not considered believable by the committee.

Those in favour of the price can refer to Kroll’s valuation of $14.18 to $14.38 per ADS with the application of the final discounted cash flow approach. The offer itself means a  19.7% premium to the closing price on 6 November, while the stock price can go down in case the offer is unsuccessful.

We do not consider the comparison of the offer with DoubleDown’s cash as a valuation but as an illustration. In addition, withholding tax should also be considered in order to estimate the actual amount of money the shareholders will keep. It is not reasonable to rely on a single quarter’s performance in order to evaluate the forecast up to 2030.

We consider that the access of the shareholders to any written regulation on this matter is reasonable until 10 December. On that day, they should decide whether $16.25 is the fair price or just the maximum price DoubleU can pay.