82% of Voters Want Prediction Markets Regulated as Gambling

82% of Voters Want Prediction Markets Regulated as Gambling

Key Points

  • 82% of voters support gambling rules in prediction markets according to a poll conducted by a casino lobby group. Political supporters differed only by four points at most.
  • Only 140 voters out of a total of 2,268 participants have used prediction markets and viewed their financial risk at almost the same level as mortgage risk.
  • Fourth Circuit 2-1 decision ruled on Tuesday in favour of states, while the response from Kalshi on the Supreme Court hearing remains unknown yet.

82% of Voters Are For Gambling Rules in Prediction Markets as Kalshi Loses in Courts

Out of 2,268 voters who were asked about the application of gambling rules in sports contracts on platforms such as Kalshi, 82% supported gambling rules. Yet 140 of those who used prediction markets before considered its financial risks slightly lower than those of a mortgage. The courts now make decisions concerning the regulation of these markets ignoring both sides’ opinions.

Poll Reveals that Prediction Markets are Viewed as Gambling by Voters

The American Gaming Association (AGA), a trade association of casinos, commissioned its American Attitudes poll of 2,268 voters in September. All participants were registered voters aged 21 or older. The poll has a two-point margin of error. Respondents were asked whether sports contracts on prediction markets should be regulated as gambling or financial. 82% of voters supported the first opinion while 84% of Democrats, 82% of Republicans and 80% of independents shared the same view. 75% of participants stated that prediction market bets were similar to those of sportsbooks.

Kalshi and Polymarket deny it. The platforms claim that their contracts are federal financial derivatives and not gambling products. Registered exchanges on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) are already regulated by federal rules concerning market manipulation, surveillance and customer funds. Now courts need to decide whether or not state gambling laws can be applied in addition to these rules.

The 140 Bettors Who Saw Lower Financial Risks

The survey’s risk scale shows a different picture than its headline outcome. In general, the financial risk score associated with prediction-market trading amounted to 7.1 out of 10, being on par with cryptocurrencies and slightly ahead of casino betting at 7.0. Sports betting scored 6.9, stocks – 6.1 and 30-year mortgage – 5.2. In the group of 140 individuals, having traded on prediction-market exchanges, the financial risk score decreased to 6.4, which is just under the mortgage level of 6.5. Those numbers represent respondents’ perception of financial risk and not the losses they had sustained.

A UCLA addiction psychiatrist shared with the Guardian in February that the patients would define themselves as investors rather than gamblers. Also, the AGA stated that 50% of the respondents mistakenly believed that prediction-market platforms had been licensed by state regulators as sportsbooks. Among those, who had gambled within the last year, 85% claimed that they remembered the presence of responsible-gambling information, although this survey had measured only awareness and not behaviour. In April, the National Council on Problem Gambling called for the CFTC to ban retail margin trading and set the minimum age at 21. It stated that buying event contracts amounts to gambling.

Louisiana Sues Operators While CFTC Sues Louisiana

Unlike other states, Louisiana did not go for each individual operator separately but used prediction-market platforms as a class, naming Kalshi, Polymarket and others. Just a few hours later, the state judge ordered a temporary restraining order prohibiting named operators from offering sports event contracts. Massachusetts had previously filed a lawsuit against Kalshi back in September 2025 and claimed that sports contracts account for more than 75% of its trading volume.

On 13 November, CFTC filed a lawsuit against Louisiana. It was the twelfth time that CFTC filed a suit against a state. Chairman Michael Selig called Louisiana’s emergency lawsuit “naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt.” In turn, Liz Murrill, the Louisiana Attorney General, stated on X that “gambling has been regulated by states for 250 years.” CFTC claims to have filed legal briefs to four federal appellate courts and one state supreme court.

Four Appeal Courts’ Decisions and Kalshi Loses Three

It will be impossible for public opinion to decide whether the commodities federal law overrides the states’ gambling rules. This question is the responsibility of the courts, and so far, their decisions have been divergent. In April, Kalshi won the appeal in the Third Circuit regarding its conflict with New Jersey. Nevada won a victory at the Ninth Circuit in August, followed by Ohio and Tennessee at the Sixth Circuit on 25 September. On Tuesday, the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 that Maryland could enforce its gambling rules against Kalshi. Each of the three judges delivered their own decision. With this decision, Kalshi lost three out of four appeals court rulings. New Jersey filed a Supreme Court petition on 2 September and awaits Kalshi’s reply.

As of February, at least 20 federal cases involving prediction markets have been recognised by the Guardian. Kalshi argued to the newspaper that it is better to have a single system of regulation across the country than different gambling rules in each state. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL), New York state collects taxes of 51% on online gambling revenue, earning more than $1 billion in 2025. Categorising the contracts of the prediction markets as derivatives would mean depriving states of this taxation ability.

According to the AGA’s September 2025 survey done by YouGov, 85% saw the contracts as gambling while 80% favoured the regulation as a sportsbook. The 2026 survey was performed using Qualtrics; therefore, no comparison between the two sets of data is reliable.

What Will Happen Next on 30 November and 7 December?

There is a scheduled hearing for a preliminary injunction in Louisiana state court on 30 November. Kalshi has to reply to New Jersey’s Supreme Court petition on 7 December after getting two extensions. Kalshi also has 90 days since the Ninth Circuit denied a rehearing on 4 November to appeal to the Supreme Court in the case of Nevada. Public comments for the proposed CFTC swap rule ended on 18 November and the agency did not issue a final rule.

Expert Analysis: The Majority of the Public Won’t Decide a Legal Matter

Though the majority of voters may be for gambling regulation, that doesn’t necessarily mean that judges will come to the same conclusions because they interpret the laws. Three out of four appeals court decisions have been already issued and they all were against Kalshi. Our opinion is that the figure of 82% would matter to legislators while making a decision about future policy rather than to judges when they are supposed to interpret the current laws.

The group of 140 prediction market bettors could be as important as the one above. They considered the financial risks of such products to be the same as for mortgages. Some readers may say that those people who have experience in such trades know better than those who use it just to vote. We think that calling users investors rather than gamblers could help the prediction market platforms in their legal matters much more than the description of the contracts. Sports contracts, according to the NCSL, were responsible for about 75% to 90% of Kalshi’s turnover.

The survey was ordered by the AGA, which represents casino operators and fought against prediction markets in courts and state legislatures. The head of the organisation, Bill Miller, said that platforms trick 18-year-old people into sports betting investment. However, the AGA survey did not include anyone under 21 years old. The independent poll produced the same results as the Ipsos poll, which said that 61% considered prediction markets as a gambling and only 8% as an investment. DraftKings, FanDuel and Fanatics have quit the AGA in late 2025 which means that the association no longer represents each and every sportsbook. Caesars refused to take part in the survey saying that in October 2025 its CEO Tom Reeg said, “We will not put any of our licenses at risk”. Kalshi called the AGA’s claim of the $1 billion tax loss to be a “fake math from casinos”. We think that the survey reflects public opinion quite correctly but was paid for by an organisation interested in the result.

Would the judges follow the opinion of 82% of voters in the Louisiana court on 30 November?